Stonemill School of Business

Operational Context & FLSA Exposure

A 240,000-square-foot third-party logistics (3PL) fulfillment facility operating along the I-85 corridor employed six "Shift Logistics Assistant Supervisors". Each assistant supervisor was paid an annual salary of $42,500 ($817.31/week) and classified as exempt from Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) overtime mandates under the administrative and executive exemptions.

During peak e-commerce distribution cycles, these individuals routinely worked 50 to 56 hours per week without receiving overtime premiums. When an anonymous employee complaint was filed, the warehouse general manager sought guidance from Stonemill’s HR Practicum clinic to assess legal exposure and recommend organizational restructuring.

FLSA Audit Snapshot

  • Affected Employees: 6 Shift Logistics Leads
  • Salary Base: $42,500 / year ($20.43/hr equivalent)
  • Actual Weekly Workload: 52.4 Hours Avg (12.4 OT Hours)
  • Primary Duties Breakdown: 85% Manual Freight Handling
  • Calculated Unpaid Overtime: $28,420.00 (Past 8 Months)

The Duties Test Analysis: Executive vs. Non-Exempt Reality

Student investigator Jasmine Morales executed a rigorous two-week job duties audit, shadowing three shift leads across day and night turnarounds. To qualify for the FLSA Executive Exemption (29 CFR Part 541), three tests must be met:

FLSA Statutory Requirement Documented Job Reality Compliance Audit Status
Salary Level Test: Minimum $844/week ($43,888/year under current federal benchmark). Employees received $817.31/week ($42,500/year). FAIL (Below statutory threshold)
Primary Duty: Management of the enterprise or recognized department. 85% of time spent scanning barcodes, operating forklifts, and unloading pallets alongside hourly crew. FAIL (Routine manual labor)
Supervisory Authority: Customarily direct 2+ workers; hire/fire input. Did not conduct appraisals, discipline, or manage payroll hours; merely logged attendance. FAIL (Lacked discretionary authority)

The Four-Stage Corrective Action Plan

To eliminate liability and establish a compliant compensation architecture, Jasmine and the HR Practicum team instituted a comprehensive remediation package:

  1. Reclassification: Formally reclassified all six Shift Logistics Assistant Supervisors as non-exempt hourly employees at an hourly base rate of $21.50.
  2. Voluntary Self-Correction Back-Pay: Distributed $28,420 in retroactive overtime settlements covering the preceding 8-month period, mitigating liquidated damages risks.
  3. Electronic Timekeeping System: Mandatory clock-in/clock-out protocols with strict automated alerts for shifts exceeding 8.0 hours.
  4. Restructured Job Descriptions: Revised official job descriptions to accurately differentiate frontline Lead Material Handlers from bona fide Operations Supervisors.

Long-Term Financial & Cultural Impact

While the employer incurred an initial back-pay settlement of $28,420, the transparent reclassification prevented catastrophic Department of Labor (DOL) penalties and class-action litigation that could have exceeded $140,000.

Frontline warehouse turnover among shift leads dropped from 44% to 11% in the two quarters following reclassification, as workers felt fairly compensated for extended peak-season hours.

Case Study Source Files & Datasets

Download the authentic case documentation and anonymized timecard audit datasets.

Download Timecard Audit Dataset (.CSV) Download FLSA Analytical Brief (.TXT)

Educational Boundary Notice: Academic compliance case based on federal statutory frameworks. Does not represent formal Department of Labor determination or binding legal counsel.